> I wonder if now this ng can have a discussion on the merits of Vista vs
> Linux.
On the desktop? I've got both, and personally I prefer Vista to Ubuntu,
although putting aside all the fan-boys and trolls on either side, they both
do a very similar job.
The role of an OS is to provide a raft of services to the applications
along with a set of management/administrative tools for controlling its
behaviour and a set of basic user tools for moving and copying files, etc.
Both Linux and Vista provide all of those.
There are two reasons why I prefer Vista. Firstly, Linux is only
superficially "easy": you don't need to go very deep into its inner workings
before it gets seriously scary, with some pretty arcane terminology and
convoluted processes to follow.
Secondly, I find the user interface of Vista (and XP) to be a bit more
"polished" than any of the big Linux distros. They just feel that bit more
"messy" and "amateurish", somehow. Of course, this is entirely subjective
and many people will feel the opposite.
It used to be the case that Linux was more reliable than Windows, and had
better security. I don't think either are true, now. I took care to
install Vista onto fully compatible hardware, and I have to say it's been
totally, utterly and completely rock solid. No BSODs, no freezes - it just
keeps working. Any my machine runs continuously - the only time it gets a
reboot is on the rare occasions when an update requires it.
As for security... well, if you look at the independent monitors it's clear
that Vista has had fewer security vulnerabilities than XP did, and indeed
over the past year it's been about the same as the Linux distros, perhaps
slightly better.
So, frankly, in terms of reliability, security, and basic OS functionality,
I don't think there's much to choose between Linux and Vista. But
personally I much prefer the overall user experience of Vista compared with
any of the six Linux distros I've played with over these past few months.
And that seems to be what it boils down to: personal preference.
SteveT